Repository navigation
Consumer: Phase 3 Windows manual-session capture guide - #17
Conversation
RXY712200
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Mini lead independent review — PR #17 documentation scope PASS (reviewed at exact HEAD cf443d38eee538f04f95815287701132fcbbc77c).
Independently checked both complete changed Consumer documents, the exact diff against main 51c011d4a6e20492ed52be0d8d6eb5b9f974cb8a, actual consumers/layer-order-workbench/CMakeLists.txt options, PowerShell command usage, Windows/MinGW generator guidance, trace provenance/coverage, and links.
All exact-HEAD GitHub checks completed successfully: full-gate, mini-gate, workbench-gate, trusted scope-guard, Scope Guard selftest, and two measurement platforms. Scope Guard recognized exactly two Consumer documentation paths. No Full/Mini production, contracts, workflow, governance, tag, or Release changes.
Authorized for normal merge commit, provided the PR HEAD/base and required checks remain unchanged and GitHub accepts the merge. This note is a technical review through the repository owner's connected GitHub account, not a second independent GitHub approver.
Overall Mini Phase 3 / Step 1 is still PARTIAL — HUMAN INPUT REQUIRED: 0 of 3 genuine operator sessions have been submitted. No automation or prewritten script may be counted as human use. Preserve Issue #7 open, and do not start Step 2 or publish a new version.
Step 1 — Windows human-session preparation and independent acceptance evidence
Roadmap: #7. Final review HEAD:
cf443d38eee538f04f95815287701132fcbbc77c; verified base main:51c011d4a6e20492ed52be0d8d6eb5b9f974cb8a.Exact scope and corrections
Exactly two Consumer documentation files:
consumers/layer-order-workbench/README.zh-CN.mdandconsumers/layer-order-workbench/docs/WINDOWS-HUMAN-EXPERIENCE.zh-CN.md.No Full/Mini production, public API, build, test, shared workflow, governance, tag or release changes. No confirmed Consumer runtime defect or demonstrated Mini library defect was found during this preparation.
Local engineering evidence (not human-use evidence)
Windows 11 Pro x64, existing Visual Studio Community 2026, MSVC 19.51.36260.0, CMake 4.3.1-msvc1, Python 3.13.14. Copied only Mini and the Consumer outside the checkout; source/build/test files match the final HEAD.
Exact-HEAD GitHub evidence
Inspected runtime logs: Linux Clang ASan/UBSan actually executed Workbench 11/11, Mini 4/4, and Full 39/39 CTests successfully. CMake sanitizer options instrument the real Mini dependency and test targets. Published Mini ZIP consumer verified the official package and passed Debug/Release 11/11 tests. These are engineering checks, not real-user sessions or independent approval.
Acceptance boundary
PARTIAL — HUMAN INPUT REQUIRED. Genuine human evidence remains 0/3. Codex scripts, generated workloads and replays do not qualify. Keep this PR Draft and Issue #7 open. Successful CI and this author's review do not replace independent acceptance. Do not proceed to Step 2 or begin a new library version.